Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
about:guidelines [2026/04/29 14:18] – vso_vsoabout:guidelines [2026/05/08 20:58] (current) – vso_vso
Line 23: Line 23:
  
 ^ Principle ^ What it means in practice ^ ^ Principle ^ What it means in practice ^
-| **Transparency** | All contributions, including AI-assisted work, must be documented and attributed. |+| **Transparency** | All contributions, including any AI-assisted work, must be documented and attributed. |
 | **Credibility** | Every factual claim requires a source. Prefer primary sources, such as original papers, official documents, standards. | | **Credibility** | Every factual claim requires a source. Prefer primary sources, such as original papers, official documents, standards. |
 | **Triangulation** | Every topic is developed from three perspectives (actors, technology, institutions). | | **Triangulation** | Every topic is developed from three perspectives (actors, technology, institutions). |
Line 36: Line 36:
 ==== The three perspectives ==== ==== The three perspectives ====
  
-Smart grid transitions cannot be fully understood from any one disciplinary perspective. For instance, while engineering as a field allows to focus on what is technically feasible, institutional analysis highlights how rules and incentives make certain options viable. Further, exploring the perspectives of various actors underlines their distinct visions, needs and practices. Each approach illuminates something the others might miss, and each does not provide a complete outlook on any given topic. One can therefore use triangulation of different perspectives to gain a better outlook on the realities of energy transitions.+Smart grid transitions are best understood from any one disciplinary perspective. For instance, while engineering as a field allows to focus on what is technically feasible, institutional analysis highlights how rules and incentives make certain options viable. Further, exploring the perspectives of various actors underlines their distinct visions, needs and practices. Each approach illuminates something the others might miss, and each does not provide a complete outlook on any given topic. Triangulation of different perspectives helps to gain better outlook on the realities of energy transitions.
  
-Triangulation is a method from the social sciences for understanding real-world phenomena by combining multiple theoretical perspectives and methods. The aim is to compensate for the limitations of any single method and to strengthen the credibility of findings through convergence across different approaches. Using multiple perspectives in combination makes it possible to understand phenomena in a more differentiated way: to identify priorities based on a fuller picture, to spot where different framings are compatible and where they conflict, and to develop options that are robust and relevant from different viewpoints.+Triangulation is a method from the social sciences for understanding real-world phenomena by combining multiple theoretical perspectives and methods. The aim is to compensate for the limitations of any single method and to strengthen the credibility of findings through convergence across different approaches. This enables deeper understanding and helps to identify priorities based on a fuller picture, to spot where different framings are compatible and where they conflict, and to develop options that are robust and relevant from different viewpoints.
  
 <WRAP callout> <WRAP callout>
Line 45: Line 45:
 {{:0:oscardamen_perspective_overlay_traingulation.png?600|Triangulation diagram}} {{:0:oscardamen_perspective_overlay_traingulation.png?600|Triangulation diagram}}
  
-Every topic is explored from three perspectives. These are not separate sections to fill in independently; they are lenses that together give a fuller picture of how a smart grid concept operates in the real world. Where the perspectives interact, or where one uniquely exposes something the others miss, this should be made explicit in the text. The three perspectives also have some resemblance to how the wiki is structured, but this structuring works somewhat differently. While a topic might belong in the "Technologies & Infrastructure" category because of how it is commonly used, it still benefits from having three different perspectives filled out as other disciplines might have other interpretations.+Every topic is explored from three perspectives. Together, they give a fuller picture of how a smart grid concepts operates in the real world. The three perspectives have some resemblance to how the wiki is structured, but while a topic might belong in the "Technologies" category because of how it is commonly used, it still benefits from having different perspectives.
  
 <WRAP perspectives> <WRAP perspectives>